Japan's F4 vs. Taiwan's F4 Options

[wink123]

I have seen a picture of Japan's F4 compared to Taiwan's F4. Does Japan have a version of Meteor Garden?

[bestmariel]

Yeah Japan has their own version of Meteor Garden... Two actually, the real drama series (with the Japanese cast) + hana Yori Dango (anime) ... THat's where the Taiwanese Drama orginated from.

I've read once about the cast of the Japanese Drama but if you ask me, nothing compares to the F4 of Taiwan. kekeke

[muraki-chan]

i can't find pics... or i can only find taiwanese F4... can you guys post some pics?

[wink123]

Here are Japans F4:

http://i80.photobucket.com/albums/j167/col.../tsukasa3ko.jpg
http://i80.photobucket.com/albums/j167/col...narui0023ot.jpg
http://i80.photobucket.com/albums/j167/col...6/et8v4j4qq.jpg
http://i80.photobucket.com/albums/j167/col.../bscap038gy.jpg
http://i80.photobucket.com/albums/j167/col...scap00134jn.jpg

This post has been edited by wink123: Mar 26 2006 8 27 PM

[lilaznmonkee_200...]

i've seen both dramas...i derno who i prefer more..the story plot differed a little but i loved both...and i also loved the characters for both xDD i mean..i love vanness and vic but i also love matsujun and oguri shun ^^

hmmm..actually, the japanese f4 resembles the original f4 more...but then again, theyre both jap. so that would make sense >_>

This post has been edited by lilaznmonkee_2008: Mar 27 2006 10 50 AM

[5566fan]

well, no offence...but the only good-looking one in the Japanese cast is the one who plays Hanazawa Rei...but maybe it's just because it's a bit old so their hairstyles are a bit old...but yea...I think the Taiwanese F4 are much more good looking...

[Pongie! :D]

japan's F4 is nothing like taiwan's F4...Taiwan's f4 is so much better. japan's f4 you can see that the cast looks a bit like the manga but other than that they're not cute at all..

[Shuwei]

As for looks, I'd say the Taiwan's are better. But the Japanese ones made me love the series AND the characters......well, except Tsukasa cause he's evil in the Jap one. But uh, I am too biased towards MatsuJun....

[tee-r-fishy]

awww...i fink jap f4 is beta....picture wise...i don't fink jap f4 r so photogenic...buh when u actualli watch 'em in hana yori dango...they're actualli really qt....

[syaz0805]

tha taiwanese F4 win because of their friendship still close after the series but the japan f4 is not a group in reality......but if arashi (matsujun group) act as a F4 i think it will be bombastic...but the problem is there are 5 person in group...so it should be F5. for me the taiwan F4 is reality but japan F4 is just set for the drama...n..arashi is the true f4 with 5 people hahahahaha i'm crazy ne.......

[xLx]

for looks i mite have to SiDe wif the taiwan one..
but for acting skills..def the jP ones...
alot beta.!

[clearingsky]

Nja, I like the taiwanese F4. but I can agree with ~希希~ about their acting skills. on that bit I like the japanese one.. especially Jun......HOT HOT HOT ^^

This post has been edited by clearingsky: Mar 31 2006 8 53 PM

[ckaitie]

ow, I think both F4's are cute...

I mean.... some guys from both groups are quitte hot....

[sweet_honeydew]

ya the taiwanese F4 is like reality because they formed the group F4 but I kind of think they took that from the drama from HYD...so it's not that original! I mean it's kind of like they couldn't come up with a better name so they decided to use F4 from the drama...but then again this is just my opinion...

I never liked the taiwanese F4 group...hmm but if we were to compared them in terms of looks...I guess the taiwanese F4 does look somewhat better...but in terms of acting definitely japanese F4!

[Tarepanda]

Mehhh..... forget taiwanese F4 for me... I've always disliked them and I probably won't ever like them. Never watched Meteor Gardens though, so I'm not going to say anything about it. I just don't like them, so don't go bashing at me about it or start questioning me about it...... (realize I didn't use the word... "hate"..?) But you know, I guess why I dislike taiwanese F4 so much is because of their packaging... don't the Chinese ever realize it's not mostly about the looks? Mannn... but I guess there's always people falling for the packaging, so that's what makes Chinese entertainment so successful up until now... totally pisses me off.

I'm 100% voting for Jap. F4... but technically, they're not pure "Jap" F4. Isn't Abe Tsuyoshi (guy as Akira) half Chinese...? And Matsuda Shota (Sojiro.. or the tea guy XD) studied aboard (okay, well.. he's japanese)...? Oh, what the hell... and yes, I agree Oguri Shun looks really good-looking here... As for MatsuJun, it's pretty much just the Domyouji hair pulling him down. He's a real sweetheart if you give him a chance.

[tikklles]

they are both unique in thier own wayzzzz.....have to give cridit for both groups.... but also have to admit in lookwise hands down for the taiwan f4...in actingwise hands down for the japan f4...(they were more convincing as f4)....

[Devils119]

i think i like both F4's in general as a group but when it gets down to acting and the actual drama, i like Hana Yori Dango better. I mean like F4 is supposed to be really rich and I think the Japanese F4 captures that better than Taiwan's F4.

[glitter]

Definitely Japanese F4 for me...nobody else, not even Jerry whom I liked very much, can possibly be Domyouji/DMS after Jun's perfect portrayal.

I didn't like Abe and Matsuda at all at first, but after a while they grew on me too, and I prefer them to Vanness and Ken now.

As for Shun, I like him, but I'll always like Zaizai just that bit better.

But overall, J.F4 takes the crown. C'mon, their acting is about ten levels higher than T.F4!

[sweet_honeydew]

Mehhh..... forget taiwanese F4 for me... I've always disliked them and I probably won't ever like them. Never watched Meteor Gardens though, so I'm not going to say anything about it. I just don't like them, so don't go bashing at me about it or start questioning me about it...... (realize I didn't use the word... "hate"..?) But you know, I guess why I dislike taiwanese F4 so much is because of their packaging... don't the Chinese ever realize it's not mostly about the looks? Mannn... but I guess there's always people falling for the packaging, so that's what makes Chinese entertainment so successful up until now... totally pisses me off.

I'm 100% voting for Jap. F4... but technically, they're not pure "Jap" F4. Isn't Abe Tsuyoshi (guy as Akira) half Chinese...? And Matsuda Shota (Sojiro.. or the tea guy XD) studied aboard (okay, well.. he's japanese)...? Oh, what the hell... and yes, I agree Oguri Shun looks really good-looking here... As for MatsuJun, it's pretty much just the Domyouji hair pulling him down. He's a real sweetheart if you give him a chance.

I so agree with you because we both like matsujun! but really, when the taiwanese F4 came out...I had no interest in them....like almost all my friends were like going crazy over him...but meh, I thought they were really weird/not so special...many ppl are comparing to them to the japanese F4 and saying how the look very gay/weird with their clothes...but really, they just wanted to match it with the manga...if you guys watch shun and matsujun in their other jdoramas...u actually might like them!! But what really annoys me is the fact that the taiwanese F4 is using "F4" from the drama as their group name...I mean c'mon can't they come up with a better name?? about the tea guy and abe...I've seen a interview about them on youtube...ya they're so cool..they're the youngest compared to shun and matsujun....the tea guy studied in england...he has really good english...haha he's also very shy around girls and according to shun he doesn't drink beer! lol and abe yes....I think they found him from taiwan or something and asked him to be in HYD...his mandarin is so good tho...I honestly like the japanese F4 more!

This post has been edited by sweet_honeydew: Apr 1 2006 4 58 AM

[pinkmango15]

I would have to say taiwan's F4...i rkn looks wise, taiwan wins by heaps....well...if ur talking about how they looked during the meteor garden times...now they're not as good.....jap F4 if you look closely, none of them are amazingly handsome or hot...altho jun and oguri are quite cute...but personally, when the taiwanese F4 came out, i fell in love with zai zai's extremely cute looks and jerry's "coolness" and ken and vanness weren't that bad either...so...go go taiwanese F4!!!!

[MaySins]

japan's F4 is nothing like taiwan's F4...Taiwan's f4 is so much better. japan's f4 you can see that the cast looks a bit like the manga but other than that they're not cute at all..

I would choose Japan. And no, there is no such thing as Japan F4, those actors came from separate bands. Taiwan's F4---there is no talent behind it, and yeah, F4 have looks, but for the talent, you have to go with Japan.

[tvb rocks]

they have a japan f4? wa i have only heard of tawian f4 but i like the tawian f4 does anyone have a pic of japans f4?

[ceres]

I think the Japanese F4 is cuter! Especially Oguri Shun! But the Taiwanese F4 is an actual singing group.

[vanggirlie]

i use to love taiwan's F4 but than the more i watched them the more i thought they were kind of feminine or metrosexual which is not my type. altho they are still special to me since they were the first to expose me to F4. japan's F4 are ok but i love Oguri Shun (the guy that plays Rui or Lei). he's the type of guy that i'd definitely go for. he should have been the one who played DMS or Domouyji (sp?) but Jun is ok too. so overall i have to say that they are both the same other than Oguri Shun, he's the best of all F4s'.

when i say japan or taiwan F4, i'm referring to the characters and actors who play them not the guys as a F4 group because japan doesn't have F4 but actors that played the F4 guys in the drama HYD. hopefully you understand that. so don't know if you can really compare japan F4 and taiwan F4 other than how well the actors played the characters.

This post has been edited by vanggirlie: Apr 3 2006 8 39 PM

[tee-r-fishy]

jun jun just makes da jap f4 so much more appealing...
*dis is extremely biased opinion^^"*

[rambutan.lucy]

Taiwanese F4 at least got together to act first. I really enjoyed them. As for the Japanese version, it was more a parade of fashion idols. Not impressed.

[jacciez]

they have a japan f4? wa i have only heard of tawian f4 but i like the tawian f4 does anyone have a pic of japans f4?

err don't just see the looks.. i din fancy japan's f4 until i watched them act.. actually it is just matsujun who really won me over!! haha.. his acting is superb!! tsukushi's acting is not bad too =D

[Tarepanda]

they have a japan f4? wa i have only heard of tawian f4 but i like the tawian f4 does anyone have a pic of japans f4?

You probably don't know the jap F4 because technically, they're only partners in a drama and unlike TW F4, they're not involved in any other forms of the media together.

Noww... Picture, pictures, pictures.... =) Fresh screens right off HYD.


First off... Mimasaka Akira played by Abe Tsuyoshi...


Then we have... Nishikado Sojiro played by Matsuda Shota


Third, Hanazawa Rui played by Oguri Shun


Last, but of course, not least.... Domyouji Tsukasa played by Matsumoto Jun

(eewwww... Domyouji hair!! )


And that's the general picture... (I don't want to spoil much of HYD, so I'm posting their pictures of that "scene" *wink wink*)

...someone mentioned TW F4 got together to act first. True, but it's just that TW beat Jap to the live action version first and made it awefully huge. Still, how I view it was that Jap originally had the idea first (the manga)... so Jap still rules..? ' And MatsuJun & Shun-kun still rules! XD

[tee-r-fishy]

hahaha yay...i agree...when i compare taiwan MG to jap HYD...jap 1 is so much beta.....bsides...they're da ones talented enough 2 actualli come up wif da story in da first place...luv da jap f4....JUN IS DA BEST XDXD

[glitter]

Yeah and the thing about the Jap F4, they look really ugly when you first see them, it's like WTH?!...but as you see more of them they grow on you, especially Matsujun! When I forced my friends to watch HYD they were all ganging up on him at first, saying he had fish lips and looked like a frog, etc. and now they're having to eat their words because they've all become Matsujun fans. HAH! Lol.

[KL_Mystic]

During when Meteor Garden first aired with T-F4, I'd definitely say they looked hotter than the J-F4...now they're not so great. Acting of course, was better depicted by the J-F4. Honestly IMO only Vic & Jerry in MG and Matsujun in HYD were hot.

[chibi_seiya]

Taiwan F4 is definitely cuter than Japan F4, and Taiwan F4 feels more complete as a group too. But the Japanese "Hana Yori Dango" drama was pretty good too. Drama-wise, its hard for me to pick between Meteor Garden and HYD.

[matsujun's girl]

so what re we trying to compare, HYD and MG or the characters themselves? it's hard to compare the 2 F4's since the jap F4's not really a singing group. they're just actors chosen to play F4 while the taiwanese F4 really became a grp. but if it's in terms of the portrayal of the characters of F4 i would have to go w/ the japs since they were more "loyal" to the manga. that explains the aweful matsujun/doumyoji hairstyle. another thing is that the jap production put in more effor to make their F4 look really rich. so acting-wise Jap F4 and HYD wins.

[tee-r-fishy]

onli matsujun is singer from jap f4 rite?!...well either ways...him alone singing n dacning is beta than taiwan F4....cos srzly...they were onli promoted due 2 their 'lookz'....

This post has been edited by tee-r-fishy: Apr 11 2006 1 19 PM

[shinigami012]

hm... If you all really just discussing about more about the movie... as in acting... I prefer the japanese version. They act much more better MatsuJun acts really well as Tsukasa. hehe

[Tarepanda]

onli matsujun is singer from jap f4 rite?!...well either ways...him alone singing n dacning is beta than taiwan F4....cos srzly...they were onli promoted due 2 their 'lookz'....

I'm pretty sure that's the case... Tsuyoshi is a Mainland (Chinese) actor, so I doubt he'll have anything to do with singing... Shota, I "heard" was Jun's friend's brother (connectionssss!! XD), so I think that's how he got to act in the drama in the first place (it WAS Shota's first drama, correct me if I'm wrong)...? And Shun-kun... ummm... never heard of him in a band or whatever the case is.


TW F4... They're horrible in their own little way though... People are simply fooled by looks. But I accept Vanness, the others.... mehhh... -____-''

m(_ _)m Sorry if I sounded a bit harsh, ne.

[tee-r-fishy]

yeh yeh....onli vanness can b of exception....newaiz...i don't fink ur comment was dat harsh...i mean i hafta admit...i use 2 lyk TW f4...buh even then i could neva admit dat they were too talented...i could onli admit dat vanness was gud @ singing n dancing..

[Cindy Le AKA Lyl...]

hahahhah taiwan f4 because they the best ... they all act, sing and model ... japan is kind on unpopular so ....

[Tarepanda]

^ LOL... I really don't think Jap F4 are meant to be popular anyway... they're just there to "sell" the drama, not themselves (themselves as in F4 as a group).

[tee-r-fishy]

^ LOL... I really don't think Jap F4 are meant to be popular anyway... they're just there to "sell" the drama, not themselves (themselves as in F4 as a group).

yeh...they're NOT a group....therefore u really can't judge them 2gether....individualli wise they r pwetti popular..XDXD