Hebe Tian (S.H.E), kinda...overrated... Rating Options

[jolenee]

Well, really.
There's a lot of fans for each and every one of the S.H.E members.
Though, Hebe is definitely not overrated.
She deserves it, since she has the looks, the vocals, and the attitude.
Like people have said before, everyone has their own opinions and perspectives towards things.
Just because they favour one over the others doesn't make that one overrated.

[HaibaraH]

yea..
i don't really think Hebe is overrated.. she has the looks, vocals and attitude..
but then again... S.H.E. wouldn't be S.H.E. without either of them...
i don't really know where i'm going with this but...
from what someone said in the post before... Hebe & S.H.E. have earned their fame !!

=)

[♥hippo-holic♥]

Nope!

I dont think Hebe is overrated. I mean overrated for me means being famous even without talents but Hebe is seriously not like that she is great in acting & singing & she looks so pretty too.

So i dont think she is overrated she deserves all the fame she got now & its bcoz of her hardwork, talents & not to forget her cute looks.

Go Hebe!

[maevy]

well,i like hebe very much though i'm nt SHE huge fan,i think she's cool,she sings very well,she's pretty and cute,though sumtimes she dun talk too much in front of the camera,but i still like to watch her and ignore ella and selina dorking around...hehe~~

[Kuya4307]

I dont think Hebe is overrated. As a singer she can sing and is recognised for that. Shes not getting hugely popular based on nothing like some artist these days and that what i would say overrated.

[thewonderbegins]

Everyone has diff. views. And tbh, I find all of S.H.E lovable (: I love Selina and Ella too, but I think Hebe has to be my favourite. All the members have good voices and harmonize well together, but Hebe's voice really blows me away like in 聽袁惟仁彈吉他. Selina's voice sometimes sounds too 'cute' for my liking lol
I don't find Hebe overrated at all (: I find her personality really sweet aswell from what I see on TV - she seems really quiet and... angelic? lol ^^

[Yunsias ♥]

I really don't think that Hebe is overrated. In fact, I think she is pretty much overshadowed by Ella and Selena because her face is not everywhere and she is in not much series. And she seems quite quiet. She has quite a good voice; I find that her singing is better than Selina.

[jolenee]

Everyone has diff. views. And tbh, I find all of S.H.E lovable (: I love Selina and Ella too, but I think Hebe has to be my favourite. All the members have good voices and harmonize well together, but Hebe's voice really blows me away like in 聽袁惟仁彈吉他. Selina's voice sometimes sounds too 'cute' for my liking lol
I don't find Hebe overrated at all (: I find her personality really sweet aswell from what I see on TV - she seems really quiet and... angelic? lol ^^

Haha yeah, Hebe has a very unique voice, and I agree, her voice really stands out in 聽袁惟仁彈吉他 . (one of my favourites from S.H.E)
Ella & Selina both have their own unique voices as well, but like you said, Selina's voice can be too 'cute' , and it sometimes gives me the shivers.
Ella's voice is strong, but a bit too low for my liking, and Hebe's just perfect !
However, when the three of them sing together, it's like unbelievably perfect, hah .

[aixibi]

Haha yeah, Hebe has a very unique voice, and I agree, her voice really stands out in 聽袁惟仁彈吉他 . (one of my favourites from S.H.E)
Ella & Selina both have their own unique voices as well, but like you said, Selina's voice can be too 'cute' , and it sometimes gives me the shivers.
Ella's voice is strong, but a bit too low for my liking, and Hebe's just perfect !
However, when the three of them sing together, it's like unbelievably perfect, hah .

Yep! I agree with all your comment, although not the part where Selina's voice sometimes gives you shiver coz it didn't to me, hehehe.. I like Selina & Ella's voices too, but Hebe's voice is just perfect (for me), LOVE it, and the way she sing is just awesome, like I dunno how to describe it, it's just awesome, I love the way she sing in all S.H.E's songs, damn!, she's perfect (for me).. My bro said "she has music in her voice", if you get what it means, then you'll understand..

Yes! When three of them sing together, it's unbelievably perfect and beautiful too..

[Jaeron-Q]

Hebe overrated?
Nope wouldnt ever say so, Hebe is the quiet one out of the three.
Hebe is never the one doing the talking during interviews or concerts. (I was just rewatching their PLAY concert) and Hebe didnt even say one word during the breaks between the songs, it was all Ella and Selina, Hebe only spoke when she had to.
Yet a lot of people still say Hebe is their favourite, why? Because her talent shines.
Hebe is popular because her vocals are damn good.

[Felicitationx3]

tidtod I am just simply comparing those who are over-rate and those who aren't. It is not okay to provide an example of my arguement. Just because this thread is about Hebe, does not mean I can't use a comparsion. Any do you see people agreeing with me? Yes? ^ ^;

[nightyshe]

First of all, tell me what is ur definition of overrated? Overrated actually means someone with no talent at all but he or she has been pushed up to the top to be one of the biggest star. Is Hebe one of those? Of coz not. Hebe is very talented in alot of ways. In singing, musical instruments, her cool personalities, wackiness when off-screen, her politeness and ability to write songs.

In singing, her voice stands out the most by having the more versatile vocal range. She can go low and high. What's no good about that? That's a true talent. If you ask me, I would say that Hebe's voice can really shines well out there if she's been compared to the other talented singer. She can go for solo as well. Nothing wrong with that but we wouldn't want it to be that way because we all hope that S.H.E remain intact forever.

Acting, she had proved herself in Bull Fighting isn't it? She has the cool personality and vows that she could only cry once a year. But because of the drama that need her to cry every now and then, she did it, didn't she? Her crying scenes really improved. It's a big improvement for Hebe to be able to cry so freely in front of everyone. And what do you call that? That's an acting talent. Actually Hebe did get alot of dramas and also movie but she rejected them all because she wants to focus more on her singing. She even rejected to be in a movie with Tony Leung. Selina and Ella said that many of the producers were asking for Hebe to act in their traditional drama because of her looks. She has the most versatile looks in S.H.E Selina would always stick to her princess look while Ella would go for her tomboyish look. One more thing to note, that's not a talent but it's a natural beauty. =) U can't hate her because she's beautiful.

Hebe's personalities. She seldom speaks and is very quiet in S.H.E But, hey where does the rumour comes from? Hebe and Jay...? Gosh..as if they were true. See, the attraction is that, the mysterious aura surrounding Hebe has captured the media and they wanted to write juicy news about her...and also what is it about Hebe being a lesbian? If getting close with a girl friend is called lesbian, are we all lesbian then? Then whats up with our best-friend-so-called-girl-friend? It's not Hebe's fault if the media and the paparazzi trying their best to dig out juicy news from Hebe. One more thing to note...you can't blame Hebe because she's attractive. It's the media that you should blame.

Last but not least, I definitely do not agree with Hebe being overrated. Hebe's full of talents and it's not wise to call her overrated. She deserves her popularity and fame because she worked hard for it...24/7...never give up!!!

And in the end what did she get? Jealousy from those who dislike her. It's common in this world to get jealous for the things that u can have. (no offense but that's the world nowadays)

Hebe has the largest fans base? I believe that Ella has the largest fans base followed by Hebe and then Selina. Though, the fans base differ in different countries. But of coz, S.H.E should not be judged by their solo fans base because as a group, all 3 shine brightly and have their own good qualities. Without any one of them, there wont be S.H.E. Neither member in S.H.E are overrated. It's a never-gonna-to-happen-scenario. =) Cheers.

If I did offense someone, I deeply apologise but it's my opinion so Im just being honest here with my feelings.

[elanation]

i'm a huge S.H.E fan and i especially adore Ella but just like most people in this thread, i also DO NOT find Hebe overrated. everyone in SHE are definitely talented be it singing, dancing or acting, but they do have their own fortes though. as for hebe, i think she sings really well and out of the 3, she has the wider range of voice and could play more instruments.

as for the fan base, well, it depends on how you look at it. just like what others said, Selina appeals to mostly girls and Ella has a hold of the guys while hebe covers both the male and female fans so technically speaking she has more. but i guess we all need more info on the demographics before judging who has the larger fan base.

as for the looks, the girls of SHE has different appeals of their own. their all beautiful in their own ways. selina is the 'princessy' type; ella is the pretty 'tomboyish' type; while hebe is the naturally pretty one.

[hebeaskim]

if you call hebe is ovverrated!! then evrebody is overrated!! gosh how stupid
think before <you write something!!
this thread is absolutly..........................

[Asiul_]

^ rather weak, perhaps?
if anyone should think before they write sumthing, i wouldnt think it would be the topicstarter.
look, if ur here to defend hebe[lyk i am]
at least post sumthing to strenghen ur argument.
its kinda ironic too, cos u wrote dat u should think before u write something, and u put the"<" symbol. lyk u are pointing towards urself, lol

but anyway, i wouldnt exactly find hebe overrated, to be honest. to me, she is good looking and can sing quite well. honestly, her voice in my opinion is the best. not too tomboy or too girly for my taste.
plus, she doesnt exactly get the most attention. its not as if she has the most series......

but hey, this is just all my opinion

[babeyelmo]

i don't think hebe is any better then selina or ella...but i really love her voice esp
when she does the long echoing or back voice! its nice!...haha i think that looks selina looks
better....*shrug* and when they did that suprise birthday thingy to her she seemed sad and conmcern..so she seems like a nice person as well...and ella and selina both seem like nice people as well...i guess its just different people taste and hebe seems to be the one..but i really
think a lot of people think ella is the best and better then the other 2..*shrug*

[xdefiine]

Okay,
Im a die-hearted Hebe fan.
Idk , but she just attracts me.
She is like very very cool && funny and of course, talented.
I admit that, her acting isn't that good. Actually, it is actually quite good. People say she can't act just because she can't cry.
But if you see DNYBY , She improved alot.
Her singing, rocks to the max!
To me, she is one of the talented singing in Taiwan.
When i heard LianRenWeiMian & Superstar.
I was like, " zohmygod. This is girl rules. "
She can go high , normal as well as low.
To tell the truth, when she sinngs low, i even thought is was ella. && same as when she sings high.
I love how sings. It just rules. [:
Oh, she is the reason why i started to love short hair & even cut it. [:

[pyaarhia]

hebe is not overrated...
why??

because she is not a "trying hard" artist..
she sticks to things she could do...
and it's not her fault to be as talented as she is right now..
because we know that she really did worked for the success that she'd been receiving...

[peacex]

hebe is never overrated.

her acting maybe raw in bull fighting but please, she is not even an actress to begin with. whats more i believe most who watch bull fighting will really love her like i do

her singing will never be overrated.. among SHE her voice is the best. just listen to her lai bu ji, the lyrics and singing was really good! hebe's vocals was the best! watch bai wan da ge xing if you need any solo hebe singing performance to ensure that hebe is not overrated.

frankly speaking among SHE i like hebe best. not that i hate ella nor selina but hebe's dancing and singing and talent shines in SHE when backed up by her 2 other girlfriends/teammates/bandmates.

[sweetcandy520]

I'm a HUGE and i mean HUGe fan of SHE, my favourite i have to mention is Ella but i haven't failed to recognise the good sides of the other two members. Other than their music and really cute friendship, i also love them because over all they're actually pretty equal, in terms of talent and even fans i say. They each have a side worthy of admiring.

About Hebe, she is really talented and i loved Bull Fighting soooooo much!
As to why she may have more fans...personally i think of all the members, she's the most easilty relatable. Because those who keep up with SHE would know that the relationship they share with their fans is similar to one between friends so just like how when we make friends we usually lean towards those who are not too outspoken [like ella] and rather we rather talk to someone more...normal or quite. that's hebe. Her personality is really very normal and average, i guess in a way that makes her more approachable and real in a sense.

IDK, but that's one of the things i noticed that really attracted me to her. She really presents herself as simply herself, without trying to add anything to who she is in aim to gain a attention. Quote: bai wan da ge xing ; " 我本来就是一个很boring的人" - hebe.

[Bubbly_Millionhe...]

hebe overrated? i think she is not overrated at all. if she is popular i think it's because she deserves it. hebe has the best voice in S.H.E, though my favourite voice has to be selina's. hebe's voice is versatile, she can hit low notes & high notes with ease and has a voice that everyone likes. as far as her acting goes.. i don't think hebe is a bad actress at all. her tears actually manage to move me so i give her props though she's not as experienced in the field of acting as her bandmate ella is. dancing.. hmmm.. hebe's a good dancer. she has shown improvement through the years. i'm not a fan of her dancing but hebe makes up for that by singing extremely well so i can't really complain.

lookswise, i think hebe is SUPER cute. hebe is all about cuteness to me and her quiet personality adds an aura of mysterious sexiness to her. personally i think selina is the prettier one. personality wise hebe is okay. she's quiet, polite & doesn't engage in constant bubbly bantering like ella or selina. one thing i like about hebe's personality is how she's level-headed. she ponders before she speaks which is a good thing cos the media just loves to twist your words around.

having said that i must add that i love S.H.E as a group cos without any one of them, the band wouldn't be as successful as it is now.

PS : i get that some hebe fans want to prove their point that hebe is prettier than selina but i'm sure there are other ways of voicing your thoughts other than critisising selina's looks. a simple 'hebe's looks appeal to me more' would suffice than saying that selina's face is wide, selina is plain etc etc.. beauty is in the eye of the beholder. i find it demeaning to your idol if you glorify him/her by putting down his/her bandmates.

[Felicitationx3]

Hebe is actually my fav out of all the SHE members. I am kinda indifferent about them so my opinion shouldn't be too biase. I find Hebe to be the quitest one out of the three and her "calmness" kinda holds Selina and Ella together. She is not the the most out going person yet she can still shine on stage. . . . SO I wouldn't say she is overrated.

This post has been edited by Felicitationx3: Nov 25 2008 3 59 AM

[♥cheri♥]

Hebe is not my favourite in SHE; rather, Selina is. But even so, I don't think Hebe is overrated. She has a beautiful voice, and she has a sort of "leadership" thing coming off her that makes me think she's the mature one out of the three. Selina reminds me of the little girl that needs taking care of, and Ella's the tomboy. I don't think Hebe's that pretty, but that doesn't mean she's overrated either. Personally, I think SHE would not be complete without any of the three girls.

[highopes]

i think she is kind of underated by the media cos ive read so many news about them and non praise their(s.h.e) voices. Not like news about other stars like Yoga lin etc where the media go on praising as though it is really that good. For S.H.E 's wonderful voices, ive got family members thinking that they are like those pretty vases acting cute and cant sing!

[//* tzeyuen]

i dont think she is that overrated!
its cos she can sing like well! [she's the one i like most in SHE. even though i'm not a super big fan of them, i do listen to their songs.] and frankly speaking, i like hebe's voice over ella's or selina's (: so i think its actually her voice that might have won over her supporters (:

[zhxzhx]

I think Hebe is very pretty and cute. I really love her voice talent, especially on Shuo Ni Ai Wo. She can reach high notes and I think she really improved on her singing and acting. But she doesn't talk a lot...

[★ Nicki™]

I'm not a fan of S.H.E honestly, but I have listen to their song and YES! I do love some of them. I don't think Hebe is overrated. If you compared her with other members in the group, I think the overrated should be Ella. You know, just throwing that out there, no offense to her fans. Blehh. Okay, back to the topic, Hebe has a great voice, I have listen to her song and I do like it if not love it. She didn't get to be in series much so how come she overrated, rite? The OST of Bull Fighting, [ some of the song sang by Hebe] is awesomee! I even have it on my Iphones. So no, she's not overrated.

This post has been edited by ★ Nicki™: Apr 29 2009 12 11 AM

[angelangie]

hmmm....actually i dont think hebe is overated....i dont tends to listen to SHE nowadays....but back to the days when i do listen to them....Hebe seems to be the most quiet one.....she seldom open her mouth to speak unnecessarily....unlike the other two who chatters nonstop......i wouldnt know about her composing skills as i once listen to a piece that she compose but i only founds it so so.....vocals wise she seems strong in and her acting are pretty ok for me.....

i found her acting in bull fighting to be quiet good....though there are still more to be expanded and to be honest i didnt turn every single pages of a magazine and find her there....so no i dont think she really is too overated compares to *ahem* not to mention the name.........

[aprilluv]

Hebe is overated? - gosh the person who started this overated topic is insane ... Without Hebe there's no S.H.E. period

[「kahing ♥」]

I'm not a fan of S.H.E honestly, but I have listen to their song and YES! I do love some of them. I don't think Hebe is overrated. If you compared her with other members in the group, I think the overrated should be Ella. You know, just throwing that out there, no offense to her fans. Blehh. Okay, back to the topic, Hebe has a great voice, I have listen to her song and I do like it if not love it. She didn't get to be in series much so how come she overrated, rite? The OST of Bull Fighting, [ some of the song sang by Hebe] is awesomee! I even have it on my Iphones. So no, she's not overrated.

I agree, out of S.H.E., I think that Ella is the one that is overrated and not Hebe. She is definitely talented.

[len2]

[quote name='「kahing ♥」' date='May 12 2009 4 11 PM' post='6066388']
I agree, out of S.H.E., I think that Ella is the one that is overrated and not Hebe. She is definitely talented.
[/quote

Please dont be hating just because Ella is more popular or has a bigger fanbase.

Anyway back to the topic I dont think Hebe is overrated and I dont think any member of SHE is overrated because if they are then they wont be in this business for this long or as successful.

[rain and teardro...]

i lovee hebe's voice. but i can see your point about her voice being annoying, well anyone's voice can become annoying lol.
but i think she can sing the high and low notes, while selina is better at the high notes, and ella with the low notes
i also think she's pretty. i love her new hairstyle recently
and she's quite funny

[Belle-laide]

I don't really care for S.H.E & I don't really care for Hebe.

The only song I ever heard her sing was the one she sang with Fahrenheit & I thought her voice was okay. Not memorable or amazing. So do I think she has talent? Not really because everyone can sing like that with a little practice.

[highopes]

I don't really care for S.H.E & I don't really care for Hebe.

The only song I ever heard her sing was the one she sang with Fahrenheit & I thought her voice was okay. Not memorable or amazing. So do I think she has talent? Not really because everyone can sing like that with a little practice.

have you even hear her sing live or in more songs? and if you thought everyone can sing like her with a litttle practice then i really cant imagine HOW TERRIBLE is the guy and his group in your avater!!? Please comment here only after you hear her sing live before you produce the then constructive argument that her voice is what everyone can achieve after a little practice. I am not "bashing" you because your comment is negative but because you show that you have not really hear her sing from your statement " the only song i heard" . This is quite irresponsible.

[Belle-laide]

have you even hear her sing live or in more songs? and if you thought everyone can sing like her with a litttle practice then i really cant imagine HOW TERRIBLE is the guy and his group in your avater!!? Please comment here only after you hear her sing live before you produce the then constructive argument that her voice is what everyone can achieve after a little practice. I am not "bashing" you because your comment is negative but because you show that you have not really hear her sing from your statement " the only song i heard" . This is quite irresponsible.

It is true that I have never heard her sing live & I do have to admit Fahrenheit's live singing isn't all that wonderful but that doesn't mean they can't sing. They just can't seem to keep in sync with each other but everyone of them has their own singing abilities. & I don't know how Hebe's live singing is but all I'm saying that you don't have to be born with real talent to sing like that. It's not that hard to carry a decent tune.

I've been in choir for 4 years now & every one of us who comes out of that class learns how to sing a real classic with great voice control. Some people (like me) go into the class with no singing abilities at all & yet we manged to lead our choir in many competitions & to become one of the best choirs in the east coast.

[highopes]

It is true that I have never heard her sing live & I do have to admit Fahrenheit's live singing isn't all that wonderful but that doesn't mean they can't sing. They just can't seem to keep in sync with each other but everyone of them has their own singing abilities. & I don't know how Hebe's live singing is but all I'm saying that you don't have to be born with real talent to sing like that. It's not that hard to carry a decent tune.

I've been in choir for 4 years now & every one of us who comes out of that class learns how to sing a real classic with great voice control. Some people (like me) go into the class with no singing abilities at all & yet we manged to lead our choir in many competitions & to become one of the best choirs in the east coast.

yes ,many people can carry a decent tune, however the quality of the voice is also very important, whether the voice is uncommonly good or very pleasing to the ears. I have to clarify that hebe's fans arent praising her just because she can sing in tune in CD or Live but because of her wide vocal ranges, how she can pull up a note etc and rich vocals you don't find easily , in fact some well-known musicians even said that hebe will be a powerful force in the music industry, and someone also said she is the most decent idol singer. Ive heard FRH sing individually and they really cant carry their tune. Once, one of them can't even carry a high note and thus try to laugh it off. I do believe this is a basic for a "singer". FRH cant sing live well and i really am not impressed by their singings in the CD also. Yes FRH can sing in their way, the way which a majority of people can..

anw if you are interested in listening hebe sing live, you can try her performance in "one million stars" (bai wang da ge xing).. or her concert solo...or the song "super star" live which is a clear evidence of how hebe can pull up her notes.

This post has been edited by highopes: May 19 2009 10 24 AM

[Belle-laide]

I went to see them sing "Super Star" live & I have to say Hebe seemed like she scream during the high notes rather than sing it. Needless to say, it wasn't memorable. What I consider good singing is someone who can sing from their diaphragm & have a powerful voice. & these are what Hebe lacks. What she is doing is just opening her mouth and bleating out the the lyrics. I don't consider that real singing.

I guess it's because I've actually taken vocal classes & know what "real" singing can sound like. But that's just my opinion.

I find that most of the idols today have the same bland voice & it just doesn't lure me in. I think Ella's voice is nice because it's unique. & I find that Hebe & Selina sound too much alike so their voices aren't that great to me.

[highopes]

I went to see them sing "Super Star" live & I have to say Hebe seemed like she scream during the high notes rather than sing it. Needless to say, it wasn't memorable. What I consider good singing is someone who can sing from their diaphragm & have a powerful voice. & these are what Hebe lacks. What she is doing is just opening her mouth and bleating out the the lyrics. I don't consider that real singing.

I guess it's because I've actually taken vocal classes & know what "real" singing can sound like. But that's just my opinion.

I find that most of the idols today have the same bland voice & it just doesn't lure me in. I think Ella's voice is nice because it's unique. & I find that Hebe & Selina sound too much alike so their voices aren't that great to me.

ok , then all the more you shouldnt even say FRH can sing, quote from your second message. This obviously wrong statement removed your crediblity as someone who have taken vocal classes and know what "real" singing sound like. But i want to add in that music teachers who had been judges in singing competition like "xin guang da dao" examples TaoZhe, YuanWeiRen..producers had openly said that S.H.E have talents in singing and Hebe have a powerful voice. Selina's voice is weakest in s.h.e thus she is the least popular in the group.

This post has been edited by highopes: May 21 2009 1 22 PM

[ahjoja]

Hebe is definitely not overrated. Hebe has a great voice but sometimes, during their concerts, after along performance, Hebe can run out of fuel and sing without emotions but besides that, her voice is very lovely. She can do high and low notes very well.

[Belle-laide]

ok , then all the more you shouldnt even say FRH can sing, quote from your second message. This obviously wrong statement removed your crediblity as someone who have taken vocal classes and know what "real" singing sound like. But i want to add in that music teachers who had been judges in singing competition like "xin guang da dao" examples TaoZhe, YuanWeiRen..producers had openly said that S.H.E have talents in singing and Hebe have a powerful voice. Selina's voice is weakest in s.h.e thus she is the least popular in the group.

Please note that I said that Fahrenheit has their own singing abilities. But that is way off topic here. It's impossible to compare Fahrenheit to Hebe.

& I'm not saying that Hebe doesn't have her own singing abilities. I just find that her singing isn't the best. Her voice isn't the best out there & there is nothing memorable to it for me. & it's just my opinions, so therefore I don't really care for what other judges has said about her vocal talent. I just not a fan, okay?.