I think that Gillian is prettier because when you first look at her, u will already find her cute and pretty. But when I first looked at Hebe, it took me a while until I figured out why some people like her better than Gillian. Heheh so my vote goes to Gillian! XD

I would have to go with Hebe, she does appear more mature, and can look very sexy like she did in Reaching for the stars. Gillian seems to be stuck in all these teen roles, so she doesn't have a chance to show off her grown up side.

>.< Stuck, hebe is cute while gillian is pretty. I don't know who to choose, both appeals to me but I first knew gillian before i knew hebe, so i guess my vote will go to gillian

Hmmm, tough decision have to make here.... Hebe or Gillian? Ahh..... G.i.l.l.i.a.n! She is much prettier looking that Hebe. Hebe is not a bad looking gal.. she looks sweet. But Gillian dont have a nice smile though.

gillian: she has sharper features & bigger eyes, tt gives her a more womanly look, the prettier look.

hebe: she has smaller eyes & a very young face, like ah sa, you noe a girly sorta face, so tt makes her cuter.

overall : gillian is the pretty one while hebe is the cuter one. i'm not saying this cos i love gill, it's from a neutral point of view. lols!

gillian ofcourse! i was watching this show & they r interviewing twins. then my mom happened 2 pass by & she asked me who that girl is because she's pretty. gillian! hehe..

i dnt think hebe is pretty at all. but she has the most "ok" face in SHE.

it's hard to compare the two. in terms of prettier... i think gillian is prettier... she has more of a feminine side to her than Hebe... but in terms of cuter, Hebe is a lot more adorable than gillian. the two of them have a different kind of pretty from each other...

isn't that how she usually looks like???? LOL Gillian is WAYYYY better? what's the point comparing hebe to Gillian? it's like comparing Charlene to Ella! it's a big DUHHH

I prefer Gillian, I don't really like Hebe

wow guess not mani people lyk hebe..
but i think she's CUTE (:
n PRETTY too of cos haha.
so i prefer HEBE.. also, i don really lyk gillian. but it's jus my OPINION

Hebe and Gillian are different in terms of their style but personally, I prefer Ah Gill =)

Both of them are pretty but I prefer Hebe cuz Gillian can be kinda fake sometimes

I don't know who hebe is but anyway i would choose Gillian over hebe if i know who she is.

I think Hebe and Gillian look alike sometimes.. I don't really know Gillian, but I think they're both really pretty I choose Hebe, cause she not only looks nice, she can sing really well

Hebe is pretty but I think that Gillian is beautiful--so my vote goes to her. ^^

Can't believe it--these two are being compared? Wawwww, not even!!!
It's just wrong, wrong, wrong--all wrong. It's like someone mention above: Comparing Hebe and Gillian is like comparing Charlene and Ella hahahha. The world's just gone wrong here.

Selina is more prettier than Hebe but no doubt about it that GILLIAN is way more gorgeous and beautiful and sophisticated. She's more real than any celebrities out there and that's a fact and she has just the most adorable smile.

GILLIAN IS WAY PRETTIER..THAT'S JUST MY OPINION.. I THINK SHE'S BETTER THAN EVERYONE!! I LOVE HER!! SHE'S THE MOST BEAUTIFUL THING EVER..

-VISIT THIS FORUM-
<----CLICK

In terms of raw beauty, I think Gillian is probably prettier. However, I like watching Hebe's music videos more (well S.H.E. videos with her parts). Her behaviour and mannerism captivates me more than Gillian, who gets boring after a while.

er..well...im nt really fans of either of them, but in my opinion, i find hebe prettier. dunno why, i just think tt she looks better than gillian.

Well they both are pretty in diff ways. But i think Gill's got that very classic look - she;s like perfect everyhting!! So i guess Gill. But Hebe is still pretty!

its very hard to compare them to and plus they are totally different. but anyways i pick gillian

GILLIAN ROX!!! ya i like gillian beta or over Hebe cuz i think gillian got the whole innocent look and actually i am not too sure who Hebe is. hehe ya and i guess i like twins ever since they started so ya i would perfer gillian

OMG thats a very hard one!! hebes cute and gillians preety so i dunno they're boher the same i guess

Hebe Hebe Hebe FTW!!!

For those who don't know what does the name "Hebe" means, here goes:

Derived from Greek hebos meaning "young". In Greek mythology she was the daughter of Zeus and Hera. She was a goddess of youth who acted as the cupbearer to the gods.

they both looks like sh*t without makeup. but of course that is to be expected for most "idol" singers.

gillian is prettier with makeup though. i will never understand why people think hebe is pretty, she's one of THE plainest girls i have ever seen.

I personally think its gillian looks prettier. Hebe also looks pretty but not as pretty as gillian....=)

Gillian is much prettier but i like hebe more.

Hebe is pretty but not dat pretty. She is still e prettiest in S.H.E.

I'd say Gillian.. you gotta love her eyes.. and her nose.. and her mouth.. and her face shape.. oh everything XD She looks really perfect, I envy her so much~!

although ima S.H.E fan,i have to admit,Gillian is definitely prettier.
while hebe has an aura of mystery around her.

if im a guy,i would love to have both of them!

so Gillian wins.

I think they are both pretty... I'm not a huge huge fan of SHE, but I'd say Hebe is prettier.. She's so cute! =P

hebe is so much cuter than gillian! i think she's younger too! i'd choose hebe all the way here, she's got that innocent look to me, and i don't think gillian is even in the same class as hebe. you should compare gillian to charlene

^ Lmao erm ya but this thread is about who's prettier, not who's younger. xD
Hahaa think about it, in 4 years, Gillian's gonna be 30. xD

Actually neither Gillian or Hebe is outgoing. They are the quiet ones in their groups.

HEBE is prettier to me, I think her eyes look better then Gillian's. Gillian kinda has this "scary" look on her face sometimes.

not another thread on this again. basically i'm not a fan of both of them. but since i've seen both of them in person before, i would say that both of them look good and pretty.

HEBE!!!

ppl say they're different. but sometimes i think...in Twins Gill seemed to be the shy one, the quieter one just like Hebe these days...very quiet tho still have some crazy moment lol hebe so cute. but yeah Hebe is endearing...there is that mystery aura like someone sed before she is too cool while Gill quiet. pretty face that s all there is to it. my opinion

I think both girls are overrated.
Gillian - Yes she's pretty but she's not amazingly beautiful and a lot of the time, her smiles seem fake, I don't think I've seen times when she looks happy just naturally. I don't think she can sing, dance or act, she seems so stiff. Ah Gill does seem like she can be friendly but she's too.."cool" as in sort of cold..she's very calm and serene.

Hebe - Cute and pretty girl. This girl can definitely sing, SHE is probably one of the best girl groups I've heard, they're actually in tune etc which is a miracle, I'm glad they're in the industry. However, I have yet to see her dance and act so I'll leave that bit out. She seems more natural than Ah Gill and happier.


I guess Gillian would be the prettier one but I have to say..the pictures on Google of Hebe really don't do her any justice at all.

gillian!!

one look and you'll see that she is definetly the prettier one!
hebe's not even pretty
but she's the best looking in s.h.e.

i don't think gill is cold
maybe she's just feeling conscious of herself and i think she's pretty shy that's why her smile looks fake

Gilllian no doubt.....
no need to compare...


how about comaring gillian with Michelle Ye??
who is prettier?? hard to pick???

you better be sorry, what's wrong with the name hebe. it's unique. Hebe is so much better, plus she can sing ALOT and i mean ALOT better than gillian can. twins can't even sing to save her life

Just for your info,in greek mythology,Hebe is the goddess of youth and daughter of Zeus and Hera.

No hard feelings though.

I don't think the name Hebe sounds bad, it's pretty unique.
And btw Hebe isn't her real name. Her real name is Anita, which is a very common name...but being an artist it's actually better to have a less common one. As someone in this forum has said before...there are many celebrities who is called Raymond so when people only writes Raymond (without lastname)...people will probably think 'Raymond who? Lam, Wong or Cho?"

I pick Gillian. Hebe is cute but Gillian is always pretty.. =)

gillian, even though I prefer charlene more. hebe's look is a typical look that just any other girl on the street would have, whereas gillian is a bit more pretty as in big cute eyes and face shape

gillian all the way..
no offense, but i think hebe's
just ok..
she can be pretty suntimes,
but her prettiness can never beat gill's..

Definitely Hebe. She's so much more prettier and cuter than Gillian. And besides, she's more talented than Gillian, who plain sucks at singing and acting.

I like gillian's looks better..But i think both girls r pretty in their own right but gillian's prettiness shines more due to her sweet looking face...

i would say hebe as she is more talented and seems more natural

=O Fake?... Hebe's anything but fake! She's so cute la I think Gillian seems more fake than Hebe...

The last time I posted in this thread I was more of a Twins fan than a S.H.E fan, but now I'm a bigger S.H.E fan than I am Twins haha =P They both are pretty and they both are quite sweet. In a way, Gillian may seem more mature and 'beautiful' - like, as Hebe looks a lot younger and cuter. They also both have pretty girly voices... I like Hebe more =) On TV and stuff... Although Gillian seems quite nice, Hebe appeals as more sweet and laid-back

I'm SHE fan, but I'm in HK and almost see Twins daily on media. Ah Gill is not fake at all. Twins is smart and apparently quite honest, doesn't seem very commercial. In HK, their image is clean, clever and hardworking. This matches their personalities quite well.

However, Twins in China (PRC) or Taiwan appears innocent and young. Honestly, quite fake. I think it's because they can only speak Cantonese well. The way they say non-Cantonese Chinese will leave an impression of being a little fake trying to play 16-year-old girls.

Both Hebe and Ah Gill ( and SHE and Twins ) are very honest compare with seasoned artists.

All Gill is beautiful technically, she's beautiful when fat or thin, from any angle, with any hairstyle, with most facial expression. Hebe's beautiful only on selective conditions. But I like Hebe more, attraction comprises more than raw beauty.