QUOTE (LittleDevil @ Nov 5 2007 11 32 PM)

Okay, to be honest with you, SETTV + J-Star is unbreakable. SETTV just stated that Ming Dao and Qiao En are their top artists.
What can top that, really?
And what you mean by "in this age of idol-dom," do you mean that in this kind of era, idoling is really subjective?
Because really, it IS.
Most of these days.. things are changing tremendously -- producers simply base on looks/who is more popular, and doesn't really go by skill.
No, you're right. That's pretty much what I meant.
With the current trend of idols, instead of a time where talent actually matters kinda, idols are the ones that are going to generate popularity... despite their talent. Personally, I find FRH and SHE lacking in some of the talents that Jstars boast. Most of the Jstars' males boast talent that is at least equal to (if not exceeding) the talent that FRH has. MingDao, Shaowei, Yurong, even Renfu and Xiezhi (Mr. Fighting, anyone?). And singing, yeah, but in terms of acting and stuff, I think QiaoEn, XiaoQiao, and Song ZhiAi can hold their own against SHE as well (in some cases, I think those three EXCEL much more at acting than SHE's girls).
It's just that, for some reason, the trend in Taiwan right now isn't leaning towards the more 'manly' stars that Jungiery has, but the more attractive pretty-boy idols (hence with Arron and WuZun are doing so well). In the past, "manly" idols WERE quite attractive. Now... Taiwan's moving beyond that. Personally, I feel that all of Jstars has spades enough in talent to make up for what their looks lack, BUT like you said: idoling is so subjective these days that most people will just blindly follow their idol despite talent and skill.
QUOTE (LovesRainie @ Nov 6 2007 3 03 PM)

nanshi
haha..you sound so anti-SZ
so they can't break up?
!@#$%
I feel that Jungiery artistes would fare much better if they were signed to some other company
they are getting so little exposure nowadays..
and qiao en should be promoted well cos i feel that she's an awesome actress
just that her talents can't be shown thru jungiery
and i think many ppl don't like SZ
that's why they don't want to hire jungiery ppl..
No I am quite anti-Sun Zhong. I WAS a fan of him until after WZBQW, and then he started treating his members obviously very unfairly. Qiao En's case especially. She is just SO talented and DESERVES to be in a lot of dramas and a chance at promotions to show just HOW good she is and stuff... but SZ favored MingDao obviously.
I don't necessarily think they would fare BETTER if they were signed to another company though. I mean, there are SO many idols out there floating around that it's hard for them to compete. But I think they would do better than NOW at least in terms of equality. At least they would be decently promoted. SZ has generated a lot of anti-feelings and anti-fans though, so I'm not surprised. What I AM pleased about is how it seems that people's feelings towards SZ (at least on this forum/board) do not seem to affect how they feel towards Jungiery. And I think that goes to show you how good and talented Jstars are that people STILL like them and enjoy their works.
* * *
LittleDevil: I think the difference between WuZun and MingDao is that WuZun has had a choice of some REALLY great scripts and supporting casts. MingDao didn't really have that advantage. I mean, AQMFS did really well because of the supporting cast (ShaoWei, QiaoQiao, etc)... but Angel Lover and Legend of the Star Apple? Plus, even though WuZun is appearing in back-to-back dramas, it's nowhere near as much as MingDao was appearing in. I think he was filming the last few episodes of AQMFS while he was doing Angel Lover AND Star Apple...! Plus, MingDao was also very well-promoted at the time and was on almost every variety show there was out there. A lot of people have said that he got a huge head (I agree) because of that and that caused his popularity to decrease drastically because of how arrogant he was getting.
And you know MingDao's personality. It's SO much more different than WuZun's, y'know? You can get REAL tired of MingDao's immature and outlandish/boyish ways after awhile (although it is SOOO funny) but Wu Zun is more softspoken (could be because he doesn't know that much Mandarin yet) and it usually works in his favor.
I think Jungiery may have had a little something to do with MingDao's sudden drop in popularity, but I think that was because of BUSINESS decisions and not any part on MingDao's actual drop in appeal (choosing bad dramas for him to star in, overpromoting him on shows, etc). I mean, YYSJY is doing pretty well, I think. I think he just got very distasteful after WZBQW (what was up with that horrible long hair?!?!?) and was overexposed.
I do wonder though... Jstars does very very few CFs (commercial films) and advertisement sponsors, right? I mean... I used to see 5566 on a few commercials here and there... but it seems recently no sponsors want to touch them (that's kinda unreliable; I mean they're still fairly popular, there's no way NO sponsor out there would want to touch them) or SZ is refusing to let them sign for advertisements... That's very curious, because a lot of an idol's popularity has to do with exposure and frequency and not necessarily... just dramas and shows. Especially for Taiwanese fans.