Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Selena Li as Ying Ye Loi
AsianFanatics Forum > Entertainment Center > Hong Kong Entertainment > Ancient Time HK-Series > Ancient HK Series Archive > Face To Fate 布衣神相[TVB]
Pages: 1, 2, 3
tis me
In this series, Selena plays a Robin Hood-type character.. she has good martial arts skills and uses these skills to rob the rich and help the poor. She meets Raymond and they fall in love.. blah blah..

As for Selena's acting skills.. what can I say? They are not that good.. she was barely tolerable in Just Love and she didn't improve much in LMS.. and as for The Herbalist's Manual.. cluebat.gif

It'll be interesting to see how Selena handles this role also because she looks so frail! I can't really imagine her having martial arts skills..


Any thoughts/comments? or complaints?? sweat.gif
i_love_ron
hmm, if selina can be in this entertainment, then i'm sure that i can too, if i got the opportunity to be one. she is pretty lucky haha, but acting with ron ng would be more happier
tis me
Selina's appears in episode 4.. her acting has not improved.. I just hate her facial expressions!!!

No martial arts out of her yet..
~IcyC4t~
Have not see this series yet, but out of all series i see her, she hasn't really improved much, acting is same. Selina looks really fake at times and can not bring out the realness in her acting. I think if TVB lets her be a female lead (i think since 4 main charaters, and selina is one, unless it tavia), then she must be good or have the chance to improve.

I look forward to see her in this series. With Frankie again (?????, not positive) like in Herbalist manual??? hope they have better chemistry this time.
StrawB3rryz
Blehs. No improvement. It is unbelieveable that she knows Martial arts, she fits for those princessy character, those who needs saving all the time. Fragile type charater. xD.
koogurl87
...im sure they coulda pick a a dozen other actresses than her...not offense to Selena but I personally don't think she's up for the part and the character description doesn't even fit her...sigh...what were the people thinking when they were casting for the actresses? She really made me clenched and fast forward in the herbalist manual series already...and now she's paired with ray blush.gif welll lets just hope for the best... unsure.gif
~Akane~
lol this is becoming more of a Selena hate thread.... although I haven't got a good first impression of her and totally dislike her in Real Kung Fu, I am willing to wait and see at least 5 episodes before commenting her in this one...just to be fair... but I still think Nancy is better than her and more deserving of this role
_epitomy of failllll~
Lol, so far she hasnt appeared yet (in the episode i watched) but I'm not really looking forward to it, especially after her shocking performance in Herbalists Manual. (I'm still pissed off she got to end up with Frankie....)
~Akane~
QUOTE(Carista @ Aug 23 2006 11 30 AM) [snapback]2837063[/snapback]

sour_lemong: she should be ending up with Raymond, not Frankie. =)


The reference was to Herbalist Manual...my gosh I didn't finish that series...she ended up with Frankie? nOOOOooo I wanted Frankie with Michelle!
Tuoimongmo2007
QUOTE(Winnie_blueangel @ Aug 22 2006 10 06 PM) [snapback]2837179[/snapback]

The reference was to Herbalist Manual...my gosh I didn't finish that series...she ended up with Frankie? nOOOOooo I wanted Frankie with Michelle!



me too.. Michelle looks so cute in there.... i hated Selena ..i stopped watching when they got marry.... bc i kinda know the ending..i just wanted to see how cute Michelle was int hat series..kekeke infatuated.gif
Carista
haha.. i see.. i was talking about Face to Fate not The Herbalist Manual.. my bad.. =D
Mashixboi
she has a bigger part than anne right? thats just sad. but she isnt that bad of an actor
kssy
Selena needs to go back to training school. Her acting needs some major professional advices, I can't stand how she can't show the right emotions in some scenes, and I really don't like her crying, it does not touch me but just irritates the heck out of me.
~Akane~
QUOTE(kssy @ Aug 23 2006 4 31 PM) [snapback]2838134[/snapback]

Selena needs to go back to training school. Her acting needs some major professional advices, I can't stand how she can't show the right emotions in some scenes, and I really don't like her crying, it does not touch me but just irritates the heck out of me.


Yeah...she needs A LOT of improvement...I think she tries so I give her credit, she just overexaggerates a bit to the point where it gets a bit annoying
meilau629
I can't imagine Selina has good marital art skills. She usually plays the pretty princess roles that needs protection from others. I think she and Nancy should exchange roles. Does anyone agree?
tiramia
hahaha...can we all just wait to acutally see selena in more than 1/2 an ep before we make judgements? i didn't like her characters in all the previous series but she didn't do as badly as some other MHKs in their first series...before we turn this into a hate thread lets haf some more objective observations based on this series first! sweat.gif
xoxosweetheart
Well i like Selena. and i absoulutely have no problem with her. I think her acting is just fine and shes so pretty too ! I really liked her in Herbalist manual and im glad tvb is promoting selena.
asalie
QUOTE(asalie @ Aug 24 2006 3 28 PM) [snapback]2842885[/snapback]

From what I seen of her so far, I can't say her acting is decent. Her acting strikes me as unnatural and even the way she smiles also looks unnatural. She reallyyyy need to work on her emotions. Heck, when she was supposed to be angry or annoyed, she doesn't even look annoyed or anything remotely close to it.

She doesn't look comfortable onscreen and it shows.


To be fair to her, I will take back my words.

As she eases into her role, she looks a lot more comfortable onscreen and she is much better to watch. Granted, her acting is not bad; pretty decent in fact. Though it still strikes me as unnatural at times. But still, she still needs to work on her emotions.

I thought that scene of her rolling her eyes after Raymond made comments was really cute. I am starting to like her. smile.gif
tis me
QUOTE(asalie @ Aug 25 2006 3 22 AM) [snapback]2846795[/snapback]

To be fair to her, I will take back my words.

As she eases into her role, she looks a lot more comfortable onscreen and she is much better to watch. Granted, her acting is not bad; pretty decent in fact. Though it still strikes me as unnatural at times. But still, she still needs to work on her emotions.

I thought that scene of her rolling her eyes after Raymond made comments was really cute. I am starting to like her. smile.gif



I think she has improved since the last time I've seen her.. but there's still a big difference between her and her co-stars. I think the fact that her co-stars are much better makes it more obvious that her acting skills are still lacking.. and Raymond's ease in his role makes her actions/expressions seem even more exaggerated.
babi_ray
it's soo hard to imagin her as a martial arts character her looks is too sassy/girly girly to play those type of role...as for her acting well i'll give her some time cuz she's still new...she's a cute looking girl when she's not smiling
tiramia
QUOTE(MISSWINGYI @ Aug 25 2006 9 02 AM) [snapback]2848367[/snapback]

u sure its episode 4? i dont remember seeing her there...


she appears in ep.5....as for her acting, i've never acutally thought she was a horrible actress but she's improved from previous series...

but tvb really screwed up her hairstyle..it makes her chin stick out a mile duh.gif
cynthdashopaholic
i don't see selena as a good actress and i don't really like her that much no offense anyone or anything.and i can't believe that she has a bigger role than nancy i think nancy is quite a good actress but tvb is promoting selena much more which i don't know why.
tis me
I just realized that I enjoy Selena's acting much more with the Mandarin dub..

She was more irritating in the Cantonese version.. her voice is kinda unnatural when she delivers some of her lines..
~Akane~
QUOTE(tis me @ Aug 26 2006 4 04 PM) [snapback]2852960[/snapback]

I just realized that I enjoy Selena's acting much more with the Mandarin dub..

She was more irritating in the Cantonese version.. her voice is kinda unnatural when she delivers some of her lines..


lol it happens! (when the original artist suck at voice projection! sorry fans) I find voice is very important cos when I was watching (handsome siblings) Alec and Jimmy? well I really hated Alec's character in canto version but when I watched mando version I really liked his characterisation and how he expressed his character. So I find to know whether the actress/actor is good in acting you need to watch the original (in this case I take it the mando dubbed has a really good voice projection)
MOcca~
Selena actually comes out in episode 5!!
I think Selena's acting is alright.. as you watch more... her character and acting grows onto you.. and you'd start to appreciate her acting a bit more!! She isnt as bad as some people say.. she juss needs more on screen experiences to improve!!
She has obviously improved.. and i like the character she portrays in here~
Carista
MOcca, have to agree with you.. =)
i like her character too! haha.. for some reason, i don't like nancy wu's character because she's too wilful.. =x
MISSWINGYI
so far, i watched the episode where selina comes out, i watched both mando and canto, and i agree that its better when its mando for her. somehow, its just weird in canto... so yea... lolx.
elloshiions
i think selena looks pretty, but judging from what everyones saying, i think her acting wont be much of a suprise huh? well.. gotta watch and see.. then make a more logical comment on her =D

[EDIT].. i finally see what you all mean about her.. her expression really dont seem real and she seems a bit stiff.. i think nancy should of taken her role, or at least someone else to replace her.. ><
Evangeline
QUOTE(tis me @ Aug 17 2006 2 59 PM) [snapback]2814525[/snapback]

Selina's appears in episode 4.. her acting has not improved.. I just hate her facial expressions!!!

No martial arts out of her yet..


Really? I didn't see her in episode 4. I can't really say anything about her since I've never seen her act before. But from all the posts I've been reading, she seems to be a "not-so-good" actress.
~Akane~
I watched ep 5! So far I don't think I can really start commenting her character in FTF but so far she's not annoying (cos she only spoke 2 lines... sweat.gif ) But for some odd reason I think she matches with Frankie. I think she appeared looking the 'smart' type...more so than Tavia. Since Frankie is the quiet smart type they really match so far. In terms of character Fungyi is still cute...Tavia being innocent and hot headed (the rat thing) and Ray being all cheeky...

so see what happens huh?
i.luv.you
selina has potention of getting better and better roles. she's not considered to be the worst tvb actress... i think her acting has improved ....can't realy say how much.. but her facial expressions are more realistic than before..

and at least she's getting better and better in each series she played.. like look at that michelle ye.. who basically shouldn't even be a actress..becuase she doens't know or will never know how to act.. i watched all her tvb series..including her newest one chamber of love..and she just sucks.. i hate her expressions.. so wooden..she delivers a monotonous speech.. at least selina isn't like that.
AzNQ
just because shes not that popular doesn't mean shes that bad...shes exactly the same as tavia pretty much just less experience give her a break jesus!
lilsab
I actually think her acting is ok in here, not as bad as u guys say she is. Her acting did improve alot!!! I so hated her in Just Love.
MISSWINGYI
QUOTE(lovely_kairi @ Aug 28 2006 6 42 PM) [snapback]2865857[/snapback]

selina has potention of getting better and better roles. she's not considered to be the worst tvb actress... i think her acting has improved ....can't realy say how much.. but her facial expressions are more realistic than before..

and at least she's getting better and better in each series she played.. like look at that michelle ye.. who basically shouldn't even be a actress..becuase she doens't know or will never know how to act.. i watched all her tvb series..including her newest one chamber of love..and she just sucks.. i hate her expressions.. so wooden..she delivers a monotonous speech.. at least selina isn't like that.


i personalli think michelle doesnt suck at acting, i think she did a great job in eternal happiness. everybodi has their own opinions, u are saying that michelle suck, but i can also say selina suck. as for her acting, selina i meant, i dont think it sucks, but sometimes, she does it weird, and i mean in this series onli.. i think she did a good job in just love, it was realistic enough. and so far, how i see selina in this series, it isnt the best of wat ive seen of her...
tis me
It seems Selena's ex-husband is actually her "yun gong".. he saved her life.. so out of gratitude, she takes care of his mother and son.

~Akane~
Well I think Selena is better than Mandy Cho and Kate Tsui at least but I won't say that she's 'good'. I'm not denying she lacks exerience but I'm saying she is not capable of undertaking lead roles as yet. She really needs a huge dose of minor type roles to improve (like in Life Made Simple). Real Kung Fu and Just Love was just horrible. It's not that she's all that bad but she's not enough to be a lead and sustain the audience.

The point as to why she is 'bad' is because there's Nancy here to compare with. How can you deny her excellent performance in TOB and TVB still gives Selena a 'lead' in this series? That again is TVB's problem
elloshiions
selena comes out in episdoe 5.. her roles is kinda.. plain at first, wonder how shell turn up later on...?
Nirvania
I don't think her acting has improved much, but i think shes really pretty. .and i love it when raymond is messing with her
hakunamatata
i personally think that her acting skills has improved. she used to not speak naturally. but now she speaks better. at least she doesnt have irritating voice and looks.
toffees
i never watched Just Love or Life Made Simple so i don't know how she was like before Face to Fate. so this is my first time watching her. i really don't think she's all that bad. kinda natural on screen. and it's really unfair (and childish) if you just hate her because she's with Raymond.
tis me
QUOTE(toffees @ Aug 30 2006 3 32 PM) [snapback]2873523[/snapback]

i never watched Just Love or Life Made Simple so i don't know how she was like before Face to Fate. so this is my first time watching her. i really don't think she's all that bad. kinda natural on screen. and it's really unfair (and childish) if you just hate her because she's with Raymond.


I think most people are complaining about her cuz her acting is not up to par.. And to be paired with Raymond and as one of the leads in the series is unfair to actresses like Nancy, who have much better acting skills..

She's def better than Mandy Cho or Kate Tsui.. and her character in this series is likable.. so give her a chance people!
陳欣怡
Personally, I don't think she's THAT bad as everyone is commenting. She has improved and I'm starting to accept her now. Now I just need to accept the relationship with Raymond whistle.gif
MISSWINGYI
her acting's okai to me! but i dont like her character in the series! it seems as if she thinks highly of herself in there! same for tavia actualli... character onli! lolx!
Nirvania
She has potential, her expressions she makes to Raymond is so cute, i love the part where Raymond is asking the old lady that works at the hotel/restaurant about Selena's favorite dishes and she just comes out of no where
Karligirl
I've never seen Selena Li (not even her photo) until Face to Fate, but I thought she's pretty notorous since I've heard so much bad comments about her acting and as well as her look (in different forums). Therefore, I was expecting some ugly chick who would just read her lines with a wooden, expressionless face. Surprisingly, she's not as bad as everyone has claimed. Yeah, she's not as natural or convincing as someone like Sheren Tang or even Tavia, but she's holding her own pretty well. Oh well, I guess as someone has mentioned above, Raymond usually brings out the best of his co-stars. And Selena might be just that...anyhoo, I like seeing different pairing of stars, and Raymond & Selena are quite nice...and fresh...
MISSWINGYI
i think the main reason is because selina had token nancy's role, cause it used to be hers. i was like that, but as time pass, i start to accept her, although i still dont like her. i dont hate her as much, but i guess its just me, i still dont like her acting. sometimes, it seems weird, unnatural u can say, so i didnt think she deserved this role. wink.gif
SweetxSour Lemon
Selena's not bad here, I do get annoyed from her voice and expression sometimes.. but her acting isn't terrible. And I see some chemistry between her and Raymond too.
~Akane~
You know what? I reckon Selena sorta looks like Cherrie?! Kenneth's girlfriend in Love Gauranteed and Scavenger's Paradise...but Cherrie is slightly prettier ..... lol maybe its just me. She was real cute with Kenneth though...won't mind trying her with Ray!
JumboJimmy
why does everyone hate selena?

i remember when she and Jessica Hsuang was promoting their film, she had to sing a song, and in the background people were "booing" her. I thought that was just my imagination. After reading this forum, i now notice that she isn't popular.

Is there something about her that i am missing out on the news?

She looks great in the documentary show promoting this mountain trip.

I hope everyone show some courtesy and give actors/actresses support in order for them to shine through. Imagine putting yourself in their position. You wouldn't like it of people "boo" you.

You can't blame Selena. TVB keeps giving her crapy roles. In the other film with Jessica Hsuang, she played a crazy depressive sole mother about to have a baby.

I think it's that role that ruin her image and career.



tis me
I think the main reason why people are disatisfied with Selena is because she is being promoted over other more TALENTED actresses..

This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2009 Invision Power Services, Inc.