oh goodie.. a nice lengthy and valid argument

first of all.. i would like to say a few words... love your presences in this thread.. theres something worth talking about

ok... someone is to blame in the series... (here it comes) we, as human beings, have the need to put blame on others or oneself.... so... why not blame it on the china girl? why not... lol if she is the third party... why not? *shrugs* question left unanswered.. maybe its one of those indefinite questions... btw

a town always needs a scrapgoat...
"I totally respect your opinions."
thank you.. and i respect yours... or else.. we would have been kicked off of this forum... hehehe
"There are some people that others see the good in and then
there are others that people see the worst in."
true... and we cant tell whether one is right or wrong...
"I don't think that whatever I say is going to
change anything since a lot of you seem to have a lot of anger/hate towards the china girl."
no... most of us stand up for what we believe.. lol we're like martyrs... j/k j/k... maybe its only me... anyways anger/hate outburst would sound something like this:
sample anger/hate outburst: I THINK THAT CHINA GIRL SHOULD JUST GO DIE BECAUSE SHE'S A DISGRACE. WHAT KIND OF DECENT PERSON GOES AND BREAKS A HEAVEN MADE RELATIONSHIP THROUGH A FREAKIN LAME LIE. WHY, I THINK SHE SHOULD TORTURE HERSELF BEFORE SHE DIES. THATS WHAT SHE MADE YAN ZI GO THROUGH THAT B*****!
havent seen anger/hate.... maybe chelly comes close but no.. we just say we dislike her.. we'd rather see her as the bad guy... nothing wrong with that
"And don't tell me that you're not mad or angry at the china girl when you want death upon
her."
No no... i can tell you I dont "hate" her.. read my post again carefully and slowly all the parts that has death in it.. there is not me wishing for death... i did wonder how the series would be if she died... did i want her dead? no... i said many deaths would have been prevented... if she died early.. did i say i wished she died? *thinks about it* no... i did say i wouldnt be annoyed because sweet redbean had to die... did i want to put her in her graves? no.. i was actually laughing that that comment

also the part where i talked about jumpin off the cliff.. did i want her to do that? no.. i said that she knows better not to... anything else i missed? 0.o?
on wards...
"Oh and I hope no one misunderstands me about liking the china girl so much because I
really don't like her; I just think she's not as bad as people think she was. XYZ is still
number one and she'll always be the best."
dude! thanks for clearing up the misunderstanding.. ahh.. after that nice defense on china girl.. i though you were her fan instead of yan zi. i'm glad we agreed on the greatness of her character ^^
"Now about that china girl again, yes it made a lot
of people angry when she lied that she was pregnant but there's no reason to hate or dislike
her for that. Yu hao could have just get her to take a few pregnancy tests. I don't care if
people have sympathy for her or not; I don't have any sympathy for her either but I just
understand her. That's what I was getting at and trying to explain."
i think when you understand... you sympathize.. you understand meaning you can see what she sees.. you have felt what she felt.. you know what she is thinking.. what she is doing... and so you pity... no... i mean sympathize... thats all fine and dandy.. we need more "understanding" people.. hehhee i just dont understand her.. maybe thats the problem.. maybe i'm not her.. and therefore i think differently.

you think that when something breaks like that (the preg lie) that things can easily mend? We can just go on with our lives after the preg. test? that is in a dream world where everyone is "understanding" Yanzi may be an angel of a character but she's human.. and she has feelings.. china girl is human too but she's not the victim.. more like the predator when it comes to love... reminds me of the poem i read about how dangerous and nasty liars they can be... wow.. now i have an even worse image of her...

thats not good...
"trying to ruin your relationship which can only strengthen your
relationship if you two really love each other. So like I said again, I don't hate her or
dislike her, it was actually good that she was there to show how strong yu hao's and XYZ's
relationship was too."
thats why i said earlier in a single post:
"tipsypixel Posted Today, 01:12 PM
yep.. she is an important part of explaining the great love of yan zi and yu hao.. but that doesnt stop me from criticizing her"
"People can always change, I'm pretty sure that towards the end, she
really did become a better person and who was more understanding."
not to mention one of the lover is dead.
"I think she didn't know
how to handle being in love so she chose to do all the wrong things instead. I don't feel
like lying about her being pregnant that she was trying to threaten XYZ."
i saw it in that manner.. eh.. what can you say. we have totally different opinions ^^ ok.. about the being naiive part.. now THAT is a valid argument. I'll buy into that... but nothing else.. lol
"Like I said, I believe that the china girl was using the wrong methods of trying to show her love."
yeah.. you got that point through. but you know.. the wrong is still the wrong.. nothing can change that.. not even if she was naiive.. not even if she "redeemed" herself... all this talk of right and wrong brings me flashbacks of TOK ^^ fun times
"Yeah, she did back off even when she still really wanted Yu hao.
But isn't that true with real-life people too? Because when you love someone, don't you also
back off still having that tingle inside
your heart of wanting to be with the one you love. Even when you tell yourself that you have
to back off and then you do, I'm pretty sure that inside your heart,there's still a little
part of you that wants to be with him still."
is this... a comeback i see?... no... if you say its a tingle inside meaning a small left behind feeling.. explain to me this.. why on earth did she want to meet yu hao for the last time soooo many times? thats more then a tingle.. its like a battle man... okay.. if only i didnt return the outsiders i rented i would count how many times she wanted to damn meet him for the last time.. and the "real" last time caused his death.. coincidence? yeah yeah... she just cant get enough of him after backing off and only having a "tingle inside." If i was china girl.. after i knew how much i've caused.. i would back off and try to stick to my words. Be a strong woman and dont sway around like the reeds... she just calls and calls and calls... "i want to meet you again for the last time." so bothersome. *yawns* you could have said she couldnt get over him period and she couldnt back off like she said she would period. that would have been good.
"here are a lot of girls who are like XYZ, SO if a girl has the personality
like XYZ then does that mean that all those girls are trying to be like XYZ too????"

i'm not just relying on they're looks or what the bad guys say about them two dear... there are many many things that make me say that.. first of all i remembered clearly she wanted to play the piano just like yan zi.. she went into the same place yan zi use to take lessons.. she found yan zi's old music scores that yu hao still had in the house and she tried to play it like on the table.. she was talking to her self too... "wow.. yan zi must be very good at playing the piano.. all these notes look difficult" then yu hao walks in and ask if she knew how to play the piano.. and she said she just found the music score lying around and tried it.. at the end when she faced ah bao, she said she wanted to be like yan zi.. a big sister figure... also, she keeps obsessing over yan zi wanting to know what she looked like and everything... kinda like wanting to know what yu hao likes her.. why would she want to know that? duh.. to be like that so she can make yu hao love her.. simple as that...what else.. i'm sure theres more instances but.. i'll just leave it at that..
other girls like yan zi is not yan zi.. i guess i didnt clarify it enough... no one can be like yan zi.. they can try but
"Like I said, she threw herself at him because she was
willing to do anything for him, even though it looked like she was being a "whore"."
she's a whore.. hehehe its the thing.. you say she's decent but doing anything even whoring.. isnt that like bad? I can believe there is still honor in sacrificing such as in death but having sex? ehh.. no...
"By the way, about that running out of the house thing, I did recall reading someone
responding that she should have ran out of the house. I would go back and quote it for you
but I don't have much time left on the computer now. So still, she's not a bad person to me."
no need to quote, i'll just take your word for it

okay.. so you think she's a not a bad person. I dont think she's a bad person either.. I just think she's not good enough to be labelled decent as you said in your earlier post. yay! i finished replying.. now i get to go to sleep.. it was nice responding to your wonderful post! hope to see you soon!
edited: didnt see your last addition there so here is responsie ^^
"Here's another example of what I'm trying to
say: Alice likes to dress slutty. But even though Alice dresses slutty, she's a very good student in school and
she doesn't like to flirt with guys at all. Alice always cooks for her parents every night and is very polite.
Alice respects her elders and doesn't drink or do drugs. This is just an example like the china girl situation.
Now a lot of people think that Alice is a slut because she dresses slutty but she's not a slut. Get it? There is a
difference between being a slut and dressing slutty. The same goes for being a whore and doing something
that a whore would do. A slut would be someone who does dirty things that other people would call immoral
or degrading. So Alice is not a slut. I'm pretty sure you understand that.
So, for the china girl. Even though she did do something a whore would most likely do, she's not a whore.
You can't just give a girl the title of being a whore when all she did was fall in love and wanted to be with
the man she loved even if she did sleep with Yu hao. Now that's all cleared up between us I hope."
now thats just unreasonable lol ^^ how can you compare sex with dress code? theres a very heavy weight difference. either you see it as the same thing (dont know why in the world someone would do that) or you take everything lightly..
i still stick with my argument after reading your refute.. *shakes head* i'm sorry.. maybe i'm not understanding enough but i cant see how its alike.. maybe the sexual connotation of dressing slutty and and the actual act of a whoring. They are on completely different levels...
i guess i could see something in it *makes a weird face* or maybe not...
yeah.. lets just call it all cleared up.. lol it would be less messy...

thanks for making up the example though.. very thoughtful of you....
okay.. now i'm actually done responding hehe