Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Miley vs Selena?
AsianFanatics Forum > Entertainment Center > Critics Hang-out
.sugarhearts
Which one do you like better and why?

This is Selena http://www.tigerbeatmag.com/dailydish/wp-c...8/763376841.jpg incase you didnt know.

To me, well .. they both act and sing but to me Miley sings better maybe because i've only heard Selena sing a few times but acting i would say Selena. Miley was good at first in Hannah Montana but then she started to exgerrate a bit too much and i didnt like her that much no more.
superstar647
*waves* heyy nikki lol

Hmm...i agree with you.
Miley definitley sings better...i mean im not a big fan of both of themm..
but Miley has a better voicee... Selena..ive actually only heard her sing twice
sooo not muchh comment.

and Selena for acting. Miley...her acting is abit akward to me..
and yes, she exaggerates (sp?) a lot. at first i quite liked Hannah Montana, but now...
its justt okay to me.

and i like selena's acting in umm...Wizards of weaverly place..
its quitee good. imm hoping to see more of her!
cathy816x
well personally i like selena better ..
haven't heard much of selena's singing so i can't compare their voices ..
but acting def. goes to selena though i'd like to see her in more shows & miley
tends to exaggerate when her role seems simple to portray ..
imsupercheesy
Hmmm for me, I kinda prefer Miley cause she IMO, she sings and acts better. Maybe it's because of the influence by her father. Selena is okay, yeah she was good at Wizards of Waverly Place. But i still prefer Miley in Hannah Montana smile.gif
Love. Music.
Who ur name is nikki? thats mine too! random i know but i just noticed that.

Anyways back to the question.
Personally I like Selena more... i like her style more its kinda punk rock so to me she looks like shes a rockstar. while miley keeps saying she is one but she dresses like hillary duff which of course is not close to rockstar image.
I like selena's voice its really high and cute but it doenst really have much cuz it sounds like like any other preteen singing.
Miley's voice is really strong so it does catched ur attentiom but when she is on stage she seems kinda lifeless.. its like the smile she puts of is forced so thats why i dont like her as much.
Im sure both are nice girls its just that sometimes miley puts on a forced face.
mlaw0
personally i like selena better ..
She's more stylish and can singing better. I agree that Miley started to exgerrate a bit too much
friends
I think Selena wayyyy better than Miley both acting and singing.
Catstreet
Selena is cuter.
Miley is okay but she seems mean and I already know she's going to be into drugs or something.
MelonieMellyMel
Well...I like them both now. XD But I like Miley's singing better (not her talking voice though) and I like Selena's acting better. As far as interviews and stuff though, I would probably rather be around Selena but Miley isn't bad. IDK! lol
pineapple_fluff
Personally, I don't care for either. Though, I have to admit that I have found myself singing along to one or two of Miley's songs. I don't like the fact that Miley is always trying to act older than she really is. Selena, I don't know much about to be able to talk about. But either way, I wouldn't go fan-crazy to see either one.
「kahing ♥」
Um~ I haven't really seen Selena's show, but I agree, Miley tends to overreact/exaggerate a lot. But I have to admit, her singing is good. Talking about looks, I think Miley is prettier, for some reason, i find Selena's face too small, and her hair too puffy for her face. Her hair makes her face look even smaller than it really is.
2easy2love
Miley is more talented maybe and shes more popular. but i like Selena better cause she seems nicer then Miley and Miley was so mean in that youtube video. she sed shes joking but thats still mean. jus killed my image of Miley Cyrus. XP but yeah i like "7 things" and shes good looking~ better looking then Selena xD i dont hate her. im just on the okay lvl. =P
ryukkux
They are both very talented girls, but I feel as though Miley is trying to escape the disney teeny-bopper scene with her new album. Selena is still very much in the disney phase. Unfortunately, I am less fond of the new mature Miley, but perhaps when she matures even more she will be more appealing as an entertainer. I think Selena still has a lot of growth to do.
D3vilishAngoOl
I like Miley better, but hey, I haven't watched Selena's show. And for all those that say Miley tends to overreact. Isn't that how her character is?
♥hippo-holic♥
Dont like both but if i have to really choose ill pick Selena just because i think her acting is abit decent and she doesnt overreact like miley does.
Getsuga-Tensho
I'm a big fan of both of them so I really don't like to compare them....
AngelAngel
I have a soft spot for Miley, she's just a girl that wanna have fun.

I think Selena's a robot built by Disney...o.o
californiababyyy.
I like Selena, dislike Miley Cyrus. I think Selena is prettier, a better singer, a better role model, and a better actress too.
Eunny_Ting
Personally Selena's character is wayy better. Yeah , she's a good role model too. Yeah , she can act very well.
BUt I think Miley Cyrus is still a better actor , singer. I don't know why , but I like it.
But of course , Selena can act & sing pretty welll too(:
Taylor N
Selena obviously has a better attitude but I'm going to have to say neither. I don't think either of them are very impressive at singing and at the moment the only claim to fame they both really have is to Disney. Whether they have any big success outside of that has yet to be seen.
yell
I'd say Selena Gomez.
Though,
I'd pick Miley in Singing and Acting, since I think, she has more experience..
Still, Selena Gomez is Good too. smile.gif
Missladybunny
I guess Miley but she plans to leave disney. how will billy ray pay the mortgage now? loool.gif
aznlili
Miley's leaving Disney?

Anyways, I think Selena's better at acting. Miley was okay but now her acting's too exagerrated. Selena's prettier too.
golden_sunflower
QUOTE
Miley's leaving Disney?


Yeah, she's leaving Disney. Season 4 may be the last season that she'll do. After season 4, there won't be any more Hannah Montana episodes.
Elizabeth Harris
am not a big fan of them but I love Miley's The Climb. Therefore, I would choose Miley for having a great singing voice.
l3g@rd3n!a
Miley has a strong powerful voice and i personally think that she's prettier, than Selena, though she might exaggerate in her acting. And it's sad that she has a bad reputation now =/
I'm not a fan of both, but i will choose Miley over Selena, in terms of singing and looks.
Cherena
I think they're both very talented actresses. Singing wise, I would defiantly have to go with Miley. She has a very nice voice. Ahah. However, I do think that Selena is a better role model for younger girls/preteens. At least she hasn't had some crazy picture scandals like Miley and Vanessa Hudgens. The whole excuse that they are just teenagers and make mistakes is too overrated.
SoEulisLOVEDDD
I prefer Miley Cyrus more. Firstly , she has better vocals & better acting skills. As for dance , of course Selena wins for her ( another cindrella story ) , gosh that show, her dance is WHOA. Shocked. Never know that she could dance so well. As for personalities , Selena. But sometimes I don't get it , why can't ppl just forgive what Miley does?
tinystar
selena look like a sneaky backstabber...well yes i'm trying to imply she LOOK FAKE!! i hate them both.
pineapple_fluff
Personally, I prefer Selena over Miley. But I have to agree that Miley has a better singing voice (given her background). I prefer Selena's acting because it feels more natural, and I'm usually more into Selena's sense of fashion over Miley's, but that's just a personal opinion.
Denise_Dinc
I prefer Selena. Somehow she seems more natural to me. And, I don't really fancy blondes, so yeah.
Musical-Notes
I've been liking Selena A LOT more than I used to. And she's also my new fav. DC star. xD
So I choose Selena. :] I used to like Miley but I don't really like her that much anymore. I like her songs but not "her" But yeah, I love Selena! <33
kixsy
i like neither of them.
but if i had to chose, i guess it would be selena.
one look at miley and feel like my mood just got trampled by a thousand elephants. sleep.gif
m2yu
QUOTE (kixsy @ Oct 18 2009 12 52 AM) *
i like neither of them.
but if i had to chose, i guess it would be selena.
one look at miley and feel like my mood just got trampled by a thousand elephants. sleep.gif


haha! I love your post! I will choose Selena too. Although it is true that Miley can sing better. I like Selena's much more down to earth style. I don't like the way Miley act or make things 'more' than they already are. And yeah, she exaggerate too much.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2009 Invision Power Services, Inc.