Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Aska Yang vs Jam Hsiao
AsianFanatics Forum > Entertainment Center > Critics Hang-out
jeffreyhadi
who is better singer? aska or jam?
both can sing well with good vibrato and falsetto, but i personally think aska is better because his singing is very touching, whereas jam sometimes overdoes his power.
what do you guys think?
♥ InitialE
I think Aska sings better smile.gif any song he sings is good. Plus he sings with more emotion.

Jam sings well too, but sometimes I don't feel anything when he performs, like during the Golden Horse ceremony last year.
jeffreyhadi
QUOTE (Initial E @ Nov 19 2008 2 54 PM) *
I think Aska sings better smile.gif any song he sings is good. Plus he sings with more emotion.

Jam sings well too, but sometimes I don't feel anything when he performs, like during the Golden Horse ceremony last year.


yes, agree with you. both indeed have great technique of singing, just aska sings with more emotion. i feel sometimes jam wants to show off his vocal.
misskeai
ooooohhh, that's hard
i think they're both great singers
(warner is so smart to sign both of them)
i might have to disagree with the above and say jam
jam's style is so distinctive and i think he deals with the emotions of the song well too
aska's "ku qiang" gets a bit over the top at times

it really is a close one and i must say, it's only because of aska's "ku qiang" that i'm voting for jam
nosecret
Aska can sing better. Aska sings like he's conveying the story to you, ultra emotional and touching. And his voice is also very soulful, power and unique. Just listen to his LIVE performance and you will be mesmerised by his wonderful vocals.

Jam perform rock songs better cos of his big and coarse voice. He doesn't sing with much emotions. That's why Aska wins him hands down in this area.
Xiao Gong Zhu
Of course Jam Hsiao, either personality wise or singing techniques, i think he's a step better than Aska.
Also, i agree with misskeai about how he's got a distinctive voice, and a unique style~~
has everyone heard his album? the songs include lil rock, and some jazz~~` and also some soul written by Khalil biggrin.gif. worth a listen!
imasha122
I definitely think jam hsiao is a much better singer, since when he first started in the Star avenue. His current success is a proof to his talent!
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2009 Invision Power Services, Inc.