Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Is Tavia or Linda's acting better? 鍾嘉欣和杨怡,谁是好演技?
AsianFanatics Forum > Entertainment Center > Hong Kong Entertainment
Pages: 1, 2, 3
Rebecca012
Mine is Tavia of course, because she acted for 10 years and why did TVB have to promoted Linda when she cannot acts.


You can see that from HOG,HOG2, THE GEM OF LIFE, she got lots of screen time and been really popular. From then she started to sing and got her personal mv disc. and all the fa dan got less screen time. I WISH that others can be promoted but defitnetly not linda.
.sugarhearts
I remember there was a thread like this. xD
I like both but I think Tavia's acting is a little bit more better.
Most people were grateful she got Best Supporting. ;]

If you think about it, TVB promoting Linda is actually a good thing ..
lots of people usually complain about TVB promoting talentless people,
for someone like Linda, we should be grateful TVB is promoting such
a down to earth girl ~ (this sounds like i'm a fan lol)
foreverleila
Too hard of a choice for me. I mean both Tavia ands Linda are my favorite actresses.

Tavia's acting skills and crying skills are really good. You will know when she's about to cry. Her nose will turn all red and tears turns to fall out.

Linda's acting and crying skills have improved so much ever since her first series when I saw her was in "Virtues of Harmony II" and in most recent performance in "The Gem of Life," "Moonlight Resonance" and Legend of the Demigods." Great improvement.
Sarwaah
If i had to choose..
I would think that Tavia acts better than Linda but i do have to say that Linda is not bad.
She may be a lil over-promoted but like what themilkl-SUGAR said...Linda can act and promoting her isnt such a bad thing...


schu
Tavia has been with the company a lot longer (already 10 years, wow time passed fast) but I think she still is a better actress (Even when she first started compared to Linda's). But i'm a fan of Linda though (because of her character in hog)
noeybby.
Tavia, afterall she's been acting for longer too.

But I seriously like Linda more, even though Tavia is a better actress. I agree, Linda has improved so much since VOH II. I LOVE her in TGOL, AJCL, HOG and LOTD. MR was okay but you can't really blame her for crying so much, it was due to the script.
uptowngirl
This is a funny question because it's so obvious that Tavia's acting is way superior and pleasing to the eye.
Musical-Notes
>.< When I saw the question,
I was like "isn't it obvious which one's the better actress?"
no offense, though. :] I also like Linda.
but of course TAVIA's the better actress. <3
Linda still needs to act a few more years...but she's improved a lot. :] I loved her in A Journey Called Life.
lil jojo
tavia all the way through.......................

u shouldn't compared tavia to linda..cos they're from a different generation.........

cos tavia started the same year as raymond, myolie, and bernice, bosco........

but anyway...definitively tavia
SuNsEtGeR
At this moment Tavia is better.... but Linda's role in The Gem of Life is also not bad... quite a good attempt by Linda...
Ichihara Yūko
QUOTE
cos tavia started the same year as raymond, myolie, and bernice, bosco........


i dun think why can't compare them because people also compare raymond and moses and even ha yu. Moses entered entertaiment industry earlier than raymond and ha yu wayyyy earlier than raymond.
meiyoke
Tavia is from TVB acting class and unlike most of TVB actress who got in through beauty pageant. Tavia has 10 years of acting experience. Linda's acting is much better now but Tavia certainly is way better.
mizztaznchick
QUOTE (meiyoke @ Jan 9 2009 1 20 PM) *
Tavia is from TVB acting class and unlike most of TVB actress who got in through beauty pageant. Tavia has 10 years of acting experience. Linda's acting is much better now but Tavia certainly is way better.


Yea,I agree w/ u!
Truth is u cant compare these 2 becuz da answer is obvious,
Tavia hav more experience,therefore her acting skills is better
n sum ppl would say Linda's acting skills is better then Tavia,but becuz TVB promote Linda more,she gets more chances 2 improve her acting skills,while Tavia only get 1-3(or sumtimes less)dramas a yr to improved her skills...but she still proved 2 ppl her acting skills is still better^^
BTW,im not bashing Linda,its jst wat i had gather ovr da yrs readin da news...n yes i also agree dat Linda's acting skills improved alot!
澤怡.
^ She is in some series..
I think she is main in Palace Scheme which is a good thing! Hope she can portray a evil character! Really hoping for one!
Wasnt Tavia the main lead in MR as the younger generations??
Oh wells..i still vote for Tavia over Linda. Linda isnt pretty enough like Tavia and i think Tavia acts better...or maybe im just used to watching her but yeah...biggrin.gif
dan168
I think Tavia is definitely better than Linda although I like Linda as well.
I don't think anyone makes crying scenes are as convincing as Tavia's!
Akazukin
I think the answer os obvious too. Tavia certainly has better acting skill.

I don't really like Linda's acting. She is not bad in GOL but I don't buy her goodies two shoes roles. There is just the way she say things that do not convince me when she plays good girl roles, but it's quite fitting in GOL. No offense I hope. She is improving but still far from main lead supposedly standard IMO.
D.Dreams
I think Tavia's acting is better... i've seen her play many different roles and she portrays them very good. I used to like Linda a lot but after they started promoting her so much i got annoyed...but Linda has improved a lot since she first came out biggrin.gif
Saranghae
i think tavia acts better and prettier!
if Tavia was paired up with Ray in HOG, it would've been perfect.
donutzai
Hmm.. Tavia acts better and more naturally to me.
linda's acting are good too but sometimes just seem unnatural.
would like to c tavia in more drama
Cutie_GrL07
I think both are good. But Tavia's crying skills are better in my opinion. You see her eyes turn red as if she is really crying for real. Linda just started and improving but her acting so far isn't bad. She was excellent in A Journey Called Life. Linda is good when she's arguing to me for some reason. She has that look and attitude.
suki.L
I think Tavis's acting is better , she's good at playing different roles . She's been in the industry longer and Linda is over promoted. Tavia is also better at crying , she seems more natural than when Linda cries . I also think Tavia is prettier than Linda .
spech
I used to think Tavia's was better, but since watching Journey Called Life, I have to say Linda is much much improved! However, Linda's voice is a little annoying.
miyukix3
although linda isn't yet experienced as tavia, i think she still does a good job as a new actress.
however, i still like tavia's acting better (:
jse
It's hard to choose whether it's for Linda or Tavia. But, I will say that both of them are acting very well. Tavia had more years of experience than Linda. And Tavia know how to control her emotions whether it's a crying scene or other scenes, etc. But for Linda, her acting is superb as she only needed a shorter time compared to Tavia to act it well. Maybe it's her inherent talent that is very suitable for her to become an actress. Tavia....Linda....hard to choose. But for me, I will choose Tavia for her years of experience in the entertainment industry.
asianbelle
Definitely Tavia.

I definitely don't think Linda's a good actress. She may have improved from before, but that still doesn't make her a good actress.

Not everyone's a born actor/actress.
Jess-x
I like Linda's acting better. Why? becuase like for example. when she was in moonlight resonance she was like a good and dead nice character but now at the moment in The Gem of life, she is a Badass xD If you get what I mean ...you probs don't now sleep.gif oh well I tried
midnightdreamz
Tavia without a doubt!!!!! In MR, Tavia's character shines through the most!!!
Pinkmew
of coz 杨怡's acting is better la!! she is soooo good at sad scenes and crying scenes!! b4 i used to didnt pay attention to her much when she was in Yummy Yummy, cuz I was paying too much attention on Charmaine and Kevin haha... but then I've watched 杨怡's other dramas, and could rly see she's rly good... 鍾嘉欣's isnt tooo bad... but dunno... she's not my type of a fave actress... lol
beck25
Linda's acting is soo much better!!!
PSYCH! hahaha. I was kidding, but seriously.... Tavia is a much better actress. She's been in TVB for a bit now, wayyy longer than Linda. Also, Linda does not really come from an acting background. She's getting better though. But Tavia is a better actress than Linda hands down.
inkydots
i really like tavia so i think her acting is better... as for linda i think she is pretty good too when i am bored and have nothing else better to do.
o0-Eva-0o
Tavia Yeung by far!

Linda to me is...i cant really find the word at the moment but her chinese sometimes sounds funny and her nose looks like its a lil wonky...sorry Linda fans...please dont hunt me down! >.<

Tavia Yeung by far!

Linda to me is...i cant really find the word at the moment but her chinese sometimes sounds funny and her nose looks like its a lil wonky...sorry Linda fans...please dont hunt me down! >.<
tudiepthao
Compare with newcomer like Linda Tavia may win but compare with veterans Tavia isn't satisfied the quality of good actress. She should be humble.
ai.s2
tvb aint blind yuu noe,
linda has plenty of talent,,
ppl complain coz yes she is movin too fast,
tavia is a great actress, & obviously a better 1 + she has so much more experience,,
but linda is a pretty damn good actress & she keeps improving,
deir both very good & has talent
~Sue~
I like both actresses, but Tavia is obviously better than Linda in terms of acting skills. Compared to Linda, Tavia has been in the industry way longer, has more acting experience, and came from the TVB acting class, so she has received some kind of formal acting training. Unfortunately Tavia doesn't get as much recognition. Linda is improving and she will be at that level in no time.
♥ α . h
Tavia , obviously because she has more experience than Linda .
I think Tavia`s acting is a lot more natural and realistic than Linda`s .
Ichihara Yūko
QUOTE
Also, Linda does not really come from an acting background

she doesn't come from acting background is not an excuse for her bad acting. Myolie didn't come from acting class too. She was praised by netizen good acting back then. But yea, because of TC she lost everything. Linda did more series than other first place and she can trained at there. Acting school is not everything. Yes, maybe they act better when comparing a newcomer from acting and a newcomer of pageant but when just like linda entered indutry for 5 years IS NO LONGER A REASON THAT SHE IS NOT FROM ACTING CLASS.

about tavia and linda, both are good actress....
endlessjoy
Definitely Tavia. There's not much I have to say, just compare their performances in Moonlight Resonance. And overall, Linda just overacts too much sometimes, and sometimes are unable to portray the moment of the character correctly. Tavia isn't perfect on her every performance, but overall, she's pretty good, and her performance in MR was such a breakthrough.
angelicdestiny
Definitely Tavia! No doubt about that because Tavia can actually act. All Linda does is squeal in her crying scenes. Tavia is so underrated and under-promoted by TVB.
selena-fan
Why I see this topic everywhere?
Don't need to compare.. sure Tavia
bobbydoedoe
my sister thinks linda chung's acting is better. She likes her because her English is perfect in every imaginable ways unlike Tavia.
fobster #1
I personally think Tavia is better. She has the experience and has worked so hard. Linda is not bad either, they need to give her more diverse characters though.
anniephan85
QUOTE (Rebecca012 @ Jan 4 2009 12 57 PM) *
Mine is Tavia of course, because she acted for 10 years and why did TVB have to promoted Linda when she cannot acts.


You can see that from HOG,HOG2, THE GEM OF LIFE, she got lots of screen time and been really popular. From then she started to sing and got her personal mv disc. and all the fa dan got less screen time. I WISH that others can be promoted but defitnetly not linda.



I 100% agree with you. Linda's acting and singing is like crap.

QUOTE (bobbydoedoe @ Jan 25 2009 8 08 PM) *
my sister thinks linda chung's acting is better. She likes her because her English is perfect in every imaginable ways unlike Tavia.


Born and raise in Canada... Linda's English is not perfect at all.
maboroshi
Linda's acting is nothing compared to Tavia's imo. I don't understand why Linda's being more promoted more than Tavia is sleep.gif
Oddish

Tavia is nothing to be compared with Linda. Linda is well-known not like Tavia worked for ten years but her popularity is just started to rise.
o0oLaLas
of course tavia's acting is better, i say that her's is a lot better
i don't really like linda's acting , her's is so FAKE sometimes and tavia cries better than linda
Vivien.
I agree, Tavia's crying is way better than Linda's. I find Linda's crying very annoying and emotionless (not trying to offend anyone). I couldn't help to post when I saw this topic, no way should Tavia be compared to Linda. Tavia is way more versatile than Linda.
l3g@rd3n!a
No doubt, Tavia. happy.gif
She's better than Linda.

Generally, I think people think that Tavia acts better...
linda has more anti-fans compared to Tavia's. (i think)
Eripeng.net
experience/facial expression/pronounciation/body language wise, Tavia stands out alot. and, i dont get it, why compare both of them. linda, is still new. tsk.

im not a linda fan.. so.. yeah
nosecret
I think Tavia can act better. And I seen Tavia in challenging roles but not Linda. Linda's roles like quite bland, not the kinda roles to display good acting. But Linda looks smarter and more endearing.
billphan2007
i like travia better because she acts better than linda. dont have a good impression for linda since gem of life!!!!!
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2009 Invision Power Services, Inc.