Since theres a JP, TW & KR version you think there will be a HK version?
If so, who do you think will be in the cast?

I really hope not. they already have planned a china version.
I have already watched the Korean, Japanese and Taiwanese versions, i don't think i can watch the China or Hong Kong version.

3 times the charm! lol

I think it'll get ruined if they make ANOTHER installment . They should stick to how many ever they have now ; really .. its enough . I really enjoyed the Korean and Taiwanese one and I don't think HK would do the best job with it .

HK would not even think it's marketable to make these kinds of idol dramas, let alone thinking about making one.

I m a bit crazy, but i really thinking abt 1 coz i want to c who will act in! Hey, y not we guess who suit which role ?

Please no, how many times does this stupid story need to be made?! I felt like I know the whole story without ever watching one episode =.=.

Hong Kong is known as the "Si lai" (housewives) market. Honestly, it's just not profitable to make another one.

NO, please... no, don't.
This will lead to even more competition.
I've watched all three versions just to see how good they were... and even the completed manga... and I can't believe there's a mainland version coming up. There will be little chance for originality, as we see more and more productions. It's one thing to remake a drama after 3,4 years (some HK movies/dramas do remake stories after 10 years or so, i believe) but another to continuously do dramas of the same storyline.

i dont think so, cause so far almost alll of the hk series are involves loves, family matters, friendships, they kinda go together, so the chances are like 20%

i dont think hk will follow the hype and do one. tvb should stick to its sharp storylines they have. no offense to HYD(:

HK? HK as in TVB? Cause that's the biggest HK station? Anyway, I don't think it's TVB style to produce idol dramas like this. The closest thing they produced like Sunshine Heartbeat and Hearts of Fencing...well...it wasn't that great? Plus, I don't want another installment! I'm tired of this remaking of Hana Yori Dango. Taiwanese, Japanese, Korean and there's that China one. I'm so sick of it that I'm starting to dislike the story. I don't understand what's so good about it that it's remade 4 times now.

i think there is one but not for definite? i know alex fong is in it...if its happening =P

Haven't watched these idol dramas...

I am not strongly against it,

but I think TVB should keep up its own style

though it would be interesting to see who will be in the cast if they actually make the HK version of HYD